Why a Scottish law can wait years to take effect
Scottish Ministers have set a start date for more trust rules, but have not said when rules for private purpose trusts will begin.

Scottish Ministers have set a new start date for parts of a trust law that received Royal Assent nearly three years ago. Their regulations leave the Act’s rules on private purpose trusts without a start date.
That gap is not necessarily a mistake. It is an example of a power Parliament gave ministers: the power to decide when much of an Act starts to operate. To see why that matters, let’s start with what a trust does.
A trust is an arrangement in which people called trustees hold and manage property for someone else’s benefit or for a purpose. For example, a parent might place money in a trust for a child’s education. The child is a beneficiary: someone who can benefit under the trust. The trustees control the money, but must manage it according to their duties and the trust’s terms.
Those terms are often recorded in a trust deed, the document setting out how the trust is to work. The deed does not answer every question on its own. Rules made by Parliament and rules developed by courts can matter too. The Act’s explanatory notes say some of its rules are defaults: they apply unless the trust has made a different arrangement.
A private purpose trust has a different starting point. The Act describes it as a trust holding property to advance a specific purpose that is not charitable or otherwise public, and that is not solely for particular beneficiaries. It can nevertheless have beneficiaries. The Act’s explanatory notes give the example of a business owner placing company shares in trust to promote the company’s interests, with employees or family also benefiting.
The distinction matters if you want to ask who can make sure a purpose is carried out. The Act provides for a supervisor, a person who can be appointed to help ensure that a private purpose trust fulfils its purpose. It also provides for a person with an interest in that purpose to apply to a court for an order requiring steps towards it. Those provisions are written into the Act, but are not yet in force.
Royal Assent is the formal approval that turns a Bill passed by Parliament into an Act. It does not necessarily start every rule in that Act. Commencement is the point at which a particular provision starts to have legal effect. Think of the Act as the rulebook Parliament approved, and commencement as the instruction telling you when a rule becomes usable.
The Act received Royal Assent on 30 January 2024, according to the legislation record. Parliament itself specified when some provisions would start. For most others, section 88 gave Scottish Ministers the power to appoint dates through regulations: detailed legal rules made under authority granted by an Act. It also allowed them to make different provision for different purposes.
The first commencement regulations brought selected provisions into force on 26 June 2024. The new regulations appoint 14 December 2026 for another set. They were made by Scottish Ministers and signed on their behalf by Kirsten Oswald, then laid before the Scottish Parliament. The explanatory notes to the Act say commencement regulations are laid before Parliament but are not otherwise subject to a parliamentary procedure. In plain terms, ministers choose the date; this mechanism does not require a fresh parliamentary vote on that date.
That power has a consequence. A person may find a rule in an Act passed by Parliament and reasonably expect to rely on it, yet still need to check whether ministers have switched it on. Members of the Scottish Parliament can ask ministers to explain their timetable, but the choice of date under this Act belongs to ministers.
The new regulations do not give a date for the private purpose trust chapter or explain why it is waiting. They do, however, provide a bridge. A saving is a rule that preserves an older legal rule for a particular situation even though the law is otherwise changing. Imagine replacing a bridge in sections while allowing some traffic to use part of the old crossing.
Here, the regulations say a court may continue to apply relevant Scots trust-law rules repealed by the Act to a trust meeting the Act’s description of a private purpose trust. That temporary permission lasts until the Act’s definition is in force for all purposes. It does not mean every old rule automatically applies to every trust: the regulation says the court may apply an applicable rule, not that it must apply a particular one. The regulations’ explanatory note also says the saving does not change the existing court-developed law on whether an arrangement is a trust.
This is the official explanation of the bridge, not a court decision settling every possible dispute. The regulations do not identify which older rule will govern a particular trust. That depends on the arrangement and the question before the court.
Who gains from the delay? The instrument gives no evidence that any particular group benefits from holding back the private purpose rules. The saving gives courts a way to use relevant older rules during the transition. But the work of identifying those rules can fall on trustees and beneficiaries, potentially with legal costs. The regulations give no estimate of those costs or of how many trusts are affected.
Who can change the wait? Under the Act, Scottish Ministers can make further commencement regulations. The question they have not answered in this instrument is why the private purpose provisions remain on hold and when they expect to begin. Until they do, the existence of the words in the Act is not, by itself, an answer for a person trying to use them.

Keep going
Law
When does a Scottish Act actually take effect?
The building safety levy shows why an Act can become law months before ministers bring particular parts into force.
Law
Who can change Scotland’s tribunal deadlines?
A new order shows how a power granted at Westminster can be exercised by Scottish Ministers, with approval from both governments and Holyrood.
Law
Who Decides What Happens in a Criminal Trial
A Palestine Action case offers a lesson in charging, evidence, reporting restrictions and the difference between a document and a claim about it.