What a US grand jury subpoena can compel
Two pro-Palestine activists pledged to stay silent before a federal grand jury, but the legal consequences depend on what happens next.

Bridget Shergalis and Sophie Ross said they would appear before a US federal grand jury on 4 November 2026 but would not answer substantive questions. The activists’ statement to The Grayzone does not establish what happened at the planned appearance.
A subpoena is a legal demand to appear or produce evidence. It is not a criminal charge, a finding of guilt or proof that the person receiving it is the investigation’s target. But a promise to remain silent is not, by itself, an exemption from a court order.
The Grayzone says prosecutors appear to be investigating Fergie Chambers, a donor to pro-Palestine causes. That is a possibility, not an established account of the grand jury’s purpose. The outlet reports that Chambers is detained in Spain over a US extradition request, a request to transfer someone between countries for prosecution. Its account does not establish the evidence behind the allegations or the outcome of the Spanish proceedings.
Shergalis and Ross previously pleaded guilty to criminal mischief, meaning property damage, and criminal trespass, meaning unlawful entry. Those convictions concerned an action at an Elbit Systems weapons facility in Merrimack, New Hampshire. Local outlet Patch reported that their sentences included 60 days in jail, with further time deferred or suspended. That earlier case does not establish the purpose of this federal inquiry.
Here is how a federal grand jury works. A court brings together members of the public to hear evidence about possible federal crimes. They can decide whether there is enough reason to issue an indictment: a formal criminal charge. An indictment is not a conviction; a trial jury or a guilty plea can settle guilt later.
Who decides? The grand jurors vote on whether to indict and can refuse a prosecutor’s recommendation. In practice, federal prosecutors have substantial influence because they organise and present the evidence and question witnesses. A person who might be charged, and their lawyer, do not normally attend the grand jury’s sessions to challenge that presentation.
A witness can consult a lawyer before appearing and can generally step outside the grand jury room to seek advice. The lawyer does not sit beside the witness during questioning. A witness can also challenge a subpoena; a judge decides disputes brought before the court.
The Fifth Amendment, part of the US Constitution, protects a person against being forced to give answers that could incriminate them: in plain terms, answers that could help build a criminal case against them. For example, a witness asked to describe their own role in an action may have grounds to claim that protection. It is not a general right to refuse every question in order to protect someone else.
A privilege is a legal protection against disclosing certain information. The Fifth Amendment privilege concerns the witness’s own exposure to criminal prosecution. A claim can be disputed, and a judge may have to decide whether it applies. The answer depends on the question and the circumstances, not just on whether the witness has announced a refusal.
Prosecutors have another option. Under federal law, a US attorney can seek approval from senior Justice Department officials and ask a court for an immunity order. Here, immunity means that compelled answers, and evidence derived from them, cannot generally be used against the witness in a criminal case. Once the order is communicated, the witness cannot rely on the Fifth Amendment to refuse those answers.
That protection is not a promise that the witness can never be prosecuted. Prosecutors may still use genuinely independent evidence. The law also permits prosecution for perjury, meaning lying under oath, and for certain other breaches connected with the order. Immunity can therefore give prosecutors testimony while leaving the witness exposed to other legal risks.
If a witness refuses without legal justification to obey an order to testify, a judge can order civil contempt detention: imprisonment intended to persuade the witness to comply, rather than a sentence for the crime under investigation. Under federal law, that confinement cannot last beyond the relevant proceeding or grand jury term and cannot exceed 18 months. Other contempt proceedings may also be possible. Neither Shergalis’s nor Ross’s announcement establishes that a judge has ordered detention.
The wider political setting matters, but it does not identify this inquiry’s target. President Donald Trump’s memorandum of 25 September 2025 directs agencies to address what it describes as domestic terrorism and organised political violence, including activity it associates with left-wing extremism. That is a broad government policy, not evidence that every left-wing network is committing a crime or that this grand jury was convened under it.
Secrecy is the other word doing important work here. Federal rules generally bar prosecutors and grand jurors from revealing matters occurring before the grand jury, with specified exceptions. Witnesses are not automatically bound by that same rule, so they may give their own accounts. Secrecy can protect witnesses and people who are investigated but never charged; it also makes it harder for the public to test claims about what prosecutors are doing.
That leaves an uneven picture. Shergalis and Ross can build solidarity by explaining their refusal; prosecutors may gain useful evidence if testimony is lawfully compelled. The activists could bear legal costs and, depending on later orders and their responses, risk detention. Readers meanwhile have partial accounts: the precise questions, any privilege rulings and any orders following the planned appearance remain unknown. Calling the inquiry a fishing expedition is an argument about its purpose, not proof of it.

Keep going
Law
When does a Scottish Act actually take effect?
The building safety levy shows why an Act can become law months before ministers bring particular parts into force.
Law
Who can change Scotland’s tribunal deadlines?
A new order shows how a power granted at Westminster can be exercised by Scottish Ministers, with approval from both governments and Holyrood.
Law
Who Decides What Happens in a Criminal Trial
A Palestine Action case offers a lesson in charging, evidence, reporting restrictions and the difference between a document and a claim about it.