Media literacy

Who decides when company directors are penalised

Late accounts can trigger a company penalty and a separate case against a director, but different decision-makers control each outcome.

· 4 min read

Illustrate a company accounts folder splitting into two paper paths, one leading to a penalty notice and the other to a courtroom.
Illustrate a company accounts folder splitting into two paper paths, one leading to a penalty notice and the other to a courtroom.

A company can owe a penalty for late accounts while its director faces a separate criminal case. The distinction matters because the company and the director are different legal persons, and the law places duties on both.

Imagine a small company submits its annual accounts after the deadline. Accounts are financial records that help outsiders understand a company’s position. The Companies Act 2006 makes the company liable for a civil penalty, a financial charge that is not a criminal conviction. Companies House, the public body that keeps the company register, applies it automatically. The amount depends on how late the accounts arrive and whether the company is private or public.

The same Act makes failure to file accounts on time an offence for the people who were directors at the deadline. A director can defend a charge by showing they took all reasonable steps to secure filing. The company penalty is not a substitute for that case, and the director is not automatically convicted because the company owes it.

Companies House says that, in England and Wales, it decides whether to bring some prosecutions itself and refers others to the appropriate agencies. A prosecution is a criminal case brought against someone accused of an offence. The prosecutor must consider whether the evidence offers a realistic prospect of conviction and whether prosecution is in the public interest. A court, not the registrar or prosecutor, decides guilt if the charge is contested and decides any fine following conviction.

A court can also make a disqualification order, which restricts someone from being a director or managing a company without court permission. Under the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986, a court can make an order for persistent breaches of filing requirements. Disqualification is not an automatic result of filing late or of every conviction.

Companies House says that, following convictions for filing offences, 23 directors were disqualified between January and June 2026 for a combined 70 years. That total adds separate periods together; it is not one person’s punishment. The agency describes its approach as proportionate and risk-based, meaning it says it chooses action according to the seriousness and risks of a breach.

There is a public purpose behind filing. A supplier considering whether to offer credit can inspect the company’s accounts before deciding. Limited liability, which generally limits owners’ responsibility for company debts, protects owners but can leave suppliers unpaid if a company fails. Current records can help those suppliers assess the risk.

Glossary: registrar — the official responsible for the company register; civil penalty — a non-criminal financial charge; prosecution — a criminal case; disqualification — a restriction on acting as a director or managing a company.

Companies HouseCompany directorsFiling rules

AdvertisementAdvertisement

Keep going

A blank company-shaped seal is pressed into wax beside a miniature company building with a loose roof tile, showing that a register entry does not prove the company’s details are accurate. Media literacy

What a Companies House entry can tell you

The agency’s verification target counts more than completed checks, while an entry on its public register is not a guarantee of accuracy.

A hand opens a plain business payment envelope, revealing three small sketches: an unknown sender, a parcel representing the offer, and a coin beside an optional-or-required payment switch. Media literacy

How to read a business payment request

A government warning about unsolicited invoices raises three separate questions: who sent the request, what it offers and whether payment is required.